Let the past die.
Drift partner whispered this line from The Last Jedi to me during Endgame in regards to a particular scene, but the more I think about it the more it sums up my thoughts about the movie and honestly the MCU at large.
Per the avid requests for no undesirable spoiler reveals I’m going to preface this discussion with the fact that this has a lot of spoilers. Not all of them, but a lot.
I’m not referring to the actual death in the film when I say the aforementioned Star Wars thing. I can think of slightly worse ways for Natasha (Scarlett Johansson) to have gone out, but I have the kind of morbid mind that comes from living in Buffy and Game of Thrones. (At least it was more Anya than Tara, more Ygritte than Ros. “At least.”) Suffice to say I’m actually angrier about that today than I was the day I saw the film. Many more reupatble publications and bloggers have gone into this in more detail and all I have to add is speculation that I’m going to withhold out of supersition. I’m not making drift partner get into it beacause she’s even angerier and in an even more personal way (I’m exempting her from this review altogether for this reason). But one of the biggest reasons that it’s incredibly annoying is that while it’s technically an active heroic choice made by the character, it’s narratively more about the impact it has on the old guard of white boys than it is about her as a character and a woman.
That’s the past I’m saying should die.
They finally let Tony Stark (Robert Downey Jr.) die, and while it was drawn out it’s done. (Sorry, pals. Friendly reminder that this is not a Tony Stark-friendly blog.) Steve (Chris Evans) too is out of the game, thanks to wibbly-wobbly timey-wimey shenanigans that I can’t even be mad about because when I heard the spoiler I was prepared for it to be a lot dumber and more insulting. Plus, Steve’s my big brother. I want him to have happiness and a good nap, or whatever.
So of said old guard, that leaves Thor (Chris Hemsworth) – who is the subject of a lot of really unacceptable weight-related jokes – and Clint (Jeremy Renner) – who spends the entire movie doing completely unnecessary and often slightly racist things out of his manpain – and Bruce (Mark Ruffalo) – who has integrated with the Hulk and spends most of the movie explaining things or being explained to. The former goes off with the Guardians at the end, which will be fun if it’s not just one futile dick-measuring contest (futile because, c’mon Quill, Thor will win any contest with you but especially one about your alleged prowess) and the latter two are at least tentatively slated for Disney+ shows. Now, Clint matters not at all, but his show will bring in his successor-Hawkeye, Kate Bishop, so that’s useful. (We have theories about the Disney+ lineup, but again, not sharing widely from supersition.) But even if 3/5 of the old guard of white boys still stands, I want to talk about the new guard, some of whom come from Avengers 2.0 (post-Ultron) and some of whom appeared after.
That’s:
- Rhodey, aka War Machine (Don Cheadle), a disabled black man whose suit is functionally identical to Tony’s but who’s genuinely a more likable person
- Sam, aka Falcon, maybe aka Captain America (Anthony Mackie), a black man with PTSD who inherited Cap’s shield and already had his moral compass (and is already slated for another Disney+ show with…)
- Bucky, fka the Winter Soldier, maybe aka the White Wolf (Sebastian Stan), a disabled white man with PTSD who’s sort of a narrative and skillset-related blank slate since we still mostly only know him as a cipher
- Wanda, aka Scarlet Witch (Elizabeth Olsen), a white girl with PTSD (who’s Jewish and also several shades of mentally ill even if the MCU never acknowledges it), who’s one of three (3) characters strong enough to hurt Thanos using only her innate abilities (and who is also slated for a Disney+ show)
- Scott, aka Ant-Man (Paul Rudd), a white man who hits some previously-established power quotas on the team and Trojan-horses in his daughter Cassie (part of the aforementioned speculation) and already Trojan-horsed in
- Hope, aka the Wasp (Evangeline Lilly), a white woman who gets all the shit done and also seems like a likely candidate to bankroll it
- Peter P., aka Spider-Man (Tom Holland), a white boy (who should/could be Jewish) who just wants to help!! (already slated for a second solo film)
- T’Challa, aka Black Panther (Chadwick Boseman), a black man who’s the literal king of the coolest nation on Earth (already slated for a second solo film)
- Shuri, maybe also aka Black Panther (Letitia Wright), a black woman who’s the smartest person on Earth and a literal princess
- Okoye, general of the Dora Milaje (Danai Gurira), a black woman who leads the best and also coolests femael squadron of frighters
- Valkyrie, fka Brunnhilde (Tessa Thompson), a bisexual and multiracial (black/Latina/white) woman with PTSD who’s functionally immortal, now the warrior queen of Asgard, and rides a fucking pegasus
- Carol, aka Captain Marvel (Brie Larson), a white woman with PTSD (who’s coded very queerly) who’s the second of three (3) people strong enough to take out Thanos and also basically anyone, who defends the entirety of space like a badass (going to have a second solo film)
- Pepper, aka Rescue (Gwyneth Paltrow), a white woman just starting out in the hero game but those of us who knew this was a possibility screamed with delight because we have been shouting for this since Iron Man 3
- the collective Guardians (Peter Quill [Chris Pratt] the white boy, Rocket [Bradley Cooper] the gun raccoon, Groot [Vin Diesel] the deus ex tree, Drax [Dave Bautista] the brawler who’s a Filipino man under all that alien makeup, Nebula [Karen Gillan] the angry blue disabled abuse survivor, Mantis [Pom Klementieff] the aggressively optimistic empath who’s the third of three [3] people strong enough to affect Thanos and technically a Korean woman – who also have another film coming)
Do you see my point? My hope is that Endgame was Marvel killing the structure of the past, the fact that the narrative was so white/male-centered. That now we’ll be able to tell more of the stories that the rest of us want to hear, the stories that reprsent a more genuine universe. (I will point out that the first POC headlining hero and first female headlining hero are among those with more films coming and that both Guardians and Spider-Man have fairly diverse casts despite being about white guys named Peter.)
But for example: on one hand that shot of all of the female fighters was sort of pandering (you want this, eat it up) and it stung that Black Widow wasn’t present, but I still got a giddy little thrill seeing so many of my faves coexisting powerfully. It’s the giddy thrill that I got during so much of Black Panther and Captain Marvel, except since so much of this movie (which in my opinion is technically overall better than Infinity War despite its more glaringly obvious flaws) was less exciting it felt almost more thrilling by comparison. Finally! Things going in the right direction.
And I’m not even discussing the characters in the greater MCU that weren’t in the final battle. There’s Maria (Lashanna Lynch) and Monica Rambeau, Nakia (Lupita Nyong’o), MJ (Zendaya Coleman) and Ned (Jacob Batalon), everyone from the television shows that deserve more love and attention. We’re on a precipice, is my point.
We’ve been going slowly torward something greater. I just hope and pray Marvel is smart enough to see that they’re already late getting there.
–your fangirl heroine.
I just realized that I got to the end of this review and forgot to mention Doctor Strange (Benedict Cumberbatch). Suffer.